Headlines
  • An Employee Opened Fire at Molson Coors Complex One of the Largest Breweirs in U.S.Killing Five Fellow Workers Before Taking His Own Life in Wisconsin
  • Tehran Has no Plans to Quarantine Cities Despite the Devastating Virus
  • India: Delhi Violence: 32 People Killed in the Violence that Rocked Northeast Delhi Since Sunday Evening
  • Togo Opposition Calls for Protests Against Election Results
  • Algeria Confirms Second Case of Coronavirus in Africa
  • China Hopes to Have COVID-19 Epidemic Under Control by April
  • Coronavirus Total Cases: 82,143 Deaths 2,805, Recovered 32,756 Deaths in Mainland China: 2,744, South Korea 13, Italy 12, Iran 19, Japan 4, Diamond Princess Cruise Ship 4
  • South Korea's Virus Infections Near 1,600, New Cases Center on Hardest-Hit City Daegu
  • Coronavirus Cases Surge to 400 in Italy
  • 14 days on: Russian-Backed Regime Forces Capture 86 Areas in Aleppo, Idlib and Hama, 552 Persons Killed, and Over 300,000 Civilians Displaced: Turkish President Receb Tayyip Erdogan
  • Yemeni Forces Intercept, Shoot Down Saudi-Led Reconnaissance Drone in Najran
  • Saudi Arabia Suspends Umrah Pilgrimage for Fear of COVID-19
  • Jordan’s King Abdullah II Assures Jordon to Hold Legislative Election This Summer

Details

Armenia Debates Cracking Down on “Fake News” and Hate Speech

The legislative efforts come after long struggles between the government and a hostile media, much of which is controlled by figures close to the former regime.

Ani Mejlumyan/Eurasianet

Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan ( Left)

Armenia’s government is taking steps to rein in the country’s media, much of which has adopted an adversarial – and, to many, an irresponsible – approach to the post-“Velvet Revolution” authorities.

One member of parliament has introduced a law that would punish “spreading false information” by up to a two-year prison term. Another group of legislators is working on a proposal to expand a law prohibiting hate speech. Others have proposed the creation of a press regulation agency, either connected with the state or independent, to police media ethics.

The legislative measures are the government’s first systematic attempts to tackle the country’s rambunctious press, much of which is owned or controlled by figures loyal to the regime that the current government toppled in the spring of 2018. The measures also seek to regulate social media, where most of Armenia’s political discussions take place and where unknown actors with murky motives can spread harmful or false information. Actors on both sides of the political spectrum hurl vitriol that the recipients perceive as “hate speech.”

While fake news can take many forms – “Coffee Cures Cancer!” – the government proposals focus especially on its political manifestations.

Since the new government took over, “fake news” has become a political tool in the hands of former regime loyalists, argued Arman Babajanyan, an independent member of parliament. “Therefore, this problem requires legislative regulations, which of course will not completely eliminate the impact of fake news but will at least have a deterrent effect for those who use fake news as a political tool,” he wrote in a December 2 Facebook post. The next day, he introduced the draft fake news law.

Artak Hambardzumyan, a media expert who has been invited to take part in the parliament’s working group on media laws, has advocated the creation of a body modeled on the UK’s Independent Press Standards Organisation, but which would have the power to legally impose and enforce sanctions (participation in IPSO is strictly voluntary)

Countries around the world are dealing with “fake news” and disinformation, but in Armenia it has been the cause of especially sharp conflicts. Last April, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan ordered the security services to crack down; the next day the National Security Service (NSS) announced it had arrested the administrator of a satirical Facebook page critical of the government. More recently, following the U.S. assassination of Iranian General Qasem Soleimani, the NSS arrested another Facebook user who falsely claimed that Pashinyan had congratulated U.S. President Donald Trump on a “successful operation.”

The NSS used varying legal bases, such as charges of “endangering national security,” in those arrests. The new law would make fake news itself illegal. It would punish those who spread fake news or who pay others to spread it. It would, however, give producers of fake news a chance to avoid punishment – three days to report to the authorities that they had violated the law.

The question, of course, is what constitutes “fake news.”

“Fake news should be defined not only by the fact that the information is false, but also that this disinformation is created and spread deliberately in order to manipulate public opinion and discourse,” said Sargis Khandanyan, a member of parliament from Pashinyan’s My Step coalition who has been leading the media regulation efforts, in an interview with Eurasianet.

But legal ambiguity is inevitable when addressing fake news, said Gegham Vardanyan, an analyst for the Yerevan-based Media Initiative Center. “I like that a discussion has started,” he told Eurasianet. “But what is fake news? Is a satire show also fake news?”

Vardanyan also noted that Babajanyan, who introduced the legislation, was recently in the media business himself, as the founder and, until last year, editor of the news site 1in.am. “A person who is proposing this regulation should be ready to exclude it [fake news] from his own website,” Vardanyan said. “I’m sure if we look at the website we will find news that could fit into his proposed category of fake news.”

The government, too, has been accused of engaging in fake news of a sort. Some pro-government social media accounts appear to be not connected to real people, said Ani Samsonyan, a member of parliament from the opposition Bright Armenia party, during a recent forum on hate speech and fake news organized by RFE/RL. “It’s organized […] there are fake accounts working for the prime minister,” she said. “If you follow their activity long enough you realize that it has to be coordinated from one point.”

Hate speech vs. free speech

The Justice Ministry introduced legislation last August that would punish hate speech by a prison term of up to three years. (Current legislation doesn’t treat hate speech as a crime in itself, but as an aggravating factor in other crimes.) That legislation was never enacted, however, and now a working group of parliamentarians is discussing a new approach. “I hope that we’ll come up with legislation by the end of spring,” Khandanyan said.

As models, “we are mostly looking at European countries, to successful examples such as Sweden, the UK, Germany, or France,” Khandanyan said. But the law won’t apply only to the press, he said: “Regulations on combating hate speech should be universal and not be limited to media platforms,” he said. “We need to distinguish between hate speech, slurs, insults, and so on, to understand which of these should be criminalized. And only then can we think of appropriate sanctions.”

While no specific proposal has been made, the opposition Prosperous Armenia Party (PAP) has already come out against the idea. “Hate speech is a serious threat, but I’m concerned that this initiative could threaten freedom of speech,” said Naira Zohrabyan, one PAP member, during a December discussion in parliament. “The main propagators of hate speech and fake news are fake [social media] users,” she said. (Last year, the investigative news website fip.am found that PAP used an “army” of fake social media users during the 2018 parliamentary election.)

In February, a PAP deputy well known for his homophobia, Gevorg Petrosyan, also spoke out against the proposed law. “This is a mechanism to contain political dissent, because what does hate speech mean? Yes, I hate homosexuality, I hate ignorance, I hate the betrayal of the homeland, I hate all these phenomena,” he said.

A “dream” regulator

Amid the debate on government regulation of the media, some in the press are proposing that Armenian journalists need instead to police themselves.

Artak Hambardzumyan, a media expert who has been invited to take part in the parliament’s working group on media laws, has advocated the creation of a body modeled on the UK’s Independent Press Standards Organisation, but which would have the power to legally impose and enforce sanctions (participation in IPSO is strictly voluntary).

“We need a regulatory body that would be independent of the state and meanwhile has enough legislative power and resources to deal with the harms brought by social media,” Hambardzumyan told Eurasianet.

Parliament’s Khandanyan, himself a former journalist, said the idea of a self-regulating body is a “dream.” Armenia already has independent, voluntary press organizations but they have proved toothless in dealing with difficult issues in the media. “We need a strong and reputable media regulation body that will keep media outlets responsible for violating ethical norms of journalism,” he said.

This Story Was Originally Published by Eurasianet Eurasianet© 2020

Iran: Hiding the Spread of the Coronavirus and Repressing Independent Information

Immediately, Iraj Harirchi , director general of the ministry of health, denied the declaration of deputy Frahani and denounced a “propaganda war”, repeating the remarks made two days earlier by the supreme leader of the revolution Ali Khamenei. However, the next day, the member and the director general both learned that they were infected with the virus
Read More

South Africa Olympic Gymnast

South African Caitlin Rooskrantz made history last year by becoming the first gymnast in her country to win a gold medal at an international meet, earning her a spot on the nation’s Olympic team. South Africa has a poor record at the Olympics, and in gymnastics in particular
Read More

Afghanistan: U.S.-Taliban Deal

After 19 years of a grueling conflict that has claimed the lives of more than one-hundred thousand people, the war in Afghanistan may finally be coming to an end. So far, all sides seem to be respecting an agreement to reduce violence, a partial truce that came into effect last Saturday
Read More

Bangladesh Court Bans 2 Books, Orders Them Removed from Literary Festival

The court’s ruling to ban the books, “Grandma’s Dictum” and “Dia Arefin,” – both works of non-fiction – and to order them removed them from stalls at the Ekushey Book Fair occurred on the fifth anniversary of the murder of U.S.-Bangladeshi secular blogger and writer Avijit Roy. He was killed in a machete-attack by Muslim zealots as he was leaving the literary festival
Read More

Kenya Allows UN Envoy for Extrajudicial Killings for the First Time

Kenya has for the first time allowed the informal visit of a UN envoy on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions. Agnès Callamard, a French human rights expert, met with relatives of police killings in Nairobi’s slums, where hundreds of cases have left relatives and friends of victims feeling powerless
Read More

Uighur Education in US

A Sunday school in a northern Virginia suburb of Washington, D.C. is teaching the Uighur language and culture to Uighur-American youngsters as a way to counter the repression in China against Uighurs in Xinjiang Province. The school, Ana Care & Education, was founded in 2017 and was the first Sunday school in the U.S. to offer these courses
Read More

Subscribe Our You Tube Channel

Fighting Fake News

Fighting Lies






0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

19 − one =

Related Article

Posted on: Tuesday, February 25, 2020 | By: crimeandmoreworld - News Desk

How an Indigenous Filmmaker is Challenging Narratives and Boundaries

Adam Piron’s love of film began as a child. Originally from Phoenix, Arizona, the Kiowa/Mohawk filmmaker got his start in the industry as a student in the University of Southern California’s film program. He became an intern in the Native American and Indigenous Film Program at Sundance and is currently assistant curator for film at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art

Posted on: Monday, February 24, 2020 | By: crimeandmoreworld - Copy Editing Desk

A Viral Coyote-Badger Video Demonstrates the Incredible Complexity of Nature

Experiments and “rules” that eliminate context often end up framing animal behavior and ecological associations as coded, robotic and inflexible. People tend to think of animal actions as simply instinct, denying the role of thinking, plasticity and decision-making in other creature’s lives

Posted on: Sunday, February 16, 2020 | By: crimeandmoreworld - Copy Editing Desk

Our Detention System is Bankrupting Immigrants

ACCORDING TO THE Migration Policy Institute, profit is one of the driving forces behind the increasingly punitive immigration policies lobbied for by the detention industry. SB 1070, for example, known colloquially as the “Show Me Your Papers Law,” was drafted in part in 2010 at a private event held in Washington, D.C., by the conservative nonprofit American Legislative Exchange Council, or ALEC, prior to its introduction in the Arizona Legislature

Posted on: Saturday, February 15, 2020 | By: crimeandmoreworld - Copy Editing Desk

Love in the Time of Coronavirus: Two Young Russians Start Dating in Quarantine

In a story that sounds like the plot of an indie movie, Savintseva and Parfenovich, both 18, met while waiting for their evacuation plane at the airport in Wuhan, the city at the center of the outbreak. Savintseva was in China as a music journalist and Parfenovich was there as a student

Posted on: Friday, February 14, 2020 | By: crimeandmoreworld - Copy Editing Desk

When Wildlife Safety Turns into Fierce Political Debate

The longest main street in America begins at the southern limits of Island Park, Idaho, and ends an eyelash west of the Montana border. On a map of Fremont County, Island Park has the profile of an immense shoelace — 36.8 miles long

Top

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy more information

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

Close